From 9be9674441871c64dc6908e3ef54ba753c22acd9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Youwen Wu Date: Wed, 16 Oct 2024 23:30:26 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] update --- work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.pdf | Bin 451101 -> 451150 bytes work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.typ | 7 ++++--- 2 files changed, 4 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.pdf b/work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.pdf index dd159825429e7635bb232ca11c30a4aa9f99fa54..cfd98569ea9e4ff5b4fceb00b02541192160f84e 100644 GIT binary patch delta 7042 zcmZ{mWmFs7v+mL0?(S}Z;9j)26ew;50t9K1h5{u>&{Evp-HNw36nBaS0;RYWE5+gb z&$)Nq5AS>K{<8P_Ju}am+4E&`ztc^9rwfLo!qMR9a11zRGe9B^RV@9y7Qo(S83#b1 z!f4?!T_?p#RzmaoO0er3=$XW@2i=3gpGBo6wS}RKF;l$FC0rmYyX}-Y%fO_Z8vPIV z8F#6C-ZI64>ewcM8Cp$?tRIa-=0AvYtd_c6h0^6UAw*w4Qcnj`%RC@I%mwJh^at$? zuKCX*r^$r25YL_0yg9c4rw=>I{MYnHuw`N74JGly$-682_!iLg`;)85LR0apF-S6Z z;1R{L(zd;@p6nz*i{rj8Vv(7H&bSjgBuUJwEgp>V#z^#VEdX7wtE*bOgUnMT#&7sR z99=g(GjF;{5dMdJi_hCv$R#Y5kdYS8%RMa8iQUPL9l|_&p!s&Z`O_oCg)V;zjMSb1 z6sKI7g7={t*|qXpu(iWmzXjD8%C(w{{4Llf^8*Q6Kz;xr`zT5XQA^XRQWG^Q!_m>@ zitQFh)T-7cxYi%jK>?bazxs!rtx7%|tFCV?{}RkO-<$!*-;)abKHXDA5Q4b+3W%^b zXg(-jjke!1g^tXOkJEMz!cT`_sq&w-Ek4}wJzox&=re~~GVFdAQjG&@TH50iM9e#R z2$G`M)RE8kGqz}4M6(%r51^cN#;tu6K9?QUJrenFs(;#WIfK`FzuhuMpFDy+utghr zJOIxk;u)bteCwOEIz}h?rANRGIfmqOkDtiueMyle`rVxswVoR}WrceIyGqHr@kJKdF3|z`jaRM$p#Jg_hF(vWRRAlBBD$yQ+dFoCX$! zQcEpKE?3hu>T$X===posYLGGQ)HO!4xN2n5l0unT24e~JQbclRu36^U28{a|gDH-h znMvsS*k6mI3S^31j5X-P(5&rC*jo^Q!rqOiN<2l}5YWUY+?f(feCMz6YgD_{70!5M zcH8*Fhl@1fH17oN<_wJQ4}vyUZ2EX{Cbr2_K98ZiAjn5M1m4s|-k+%GX?Y;cWYA-s z6=S{RYNbza7Y@a&PRS^ia)P``$hNwL!xs(6#l#?@SWLE_KCITTE7l0FTdlQqq&)S@ zXkhYbP!FR}JqNhRg-uoTv%X*U9cTWEn=@79mo4$$gOA^t9h+?xw?=6IgUJi3iZo*= zUC2kr4(~7K@kJ~BL`b7ePXSeh#N{6+SF(|W2{KY^|PMb+R?Hgg3Xxs5omeO$cd7(ZU8@N~l+n8HHbelc;d{ zgUbt2w)4fyIBuP|QJ&e_Q-jhE-cy(I?3x?jp%o46t9xsBUeDwuB`(QmZL_xGo>3VI z)ew_`A{O&t_5xl|h3h1L+h>iv{-&cW6(#Y)f%swYV1_ts{!KRPq{jKE-^h|`H#*=> zd#EOX@@ukv^YH}TM)L1ZqFQ*1JOzDY$qOf0ox>|Nv;La=HL5Pd5D7w?@XggA-cxkh zP^xr!**rDx6aFOGo%uij^g9p%hlGM504?egw}outLrAwGig zYb4=z8jlH5PyiPlriGmUW=5p{jD%j}@DMMiCP^peJ@=o7cCWI9EM3a%swK;)zokux={6;5?anuSA(n@c<`te#Fs#I${X)*u0 z!Nt~({8g@72O+Tt!SRX9I{r};Y&egAx?PcQoTgG~S1U7T$Xm%L^b0lV&bNu=0(%fk zZcuY{=e!WyFgw;Pm87IIlq8Sn%%u?HhwoKcek(M;GmPSG*O28ShV>uYBhJ49Vl@k* zzG^x!aLM*7cW60_R&VW;nr<~yZR2!4|C>cJ?ev~+viOP__NQ1A}`Q71oyOhM%w@H@= z;2DWL_3--hTT7=cW0$flzd}ChyQzSm(jlxd%x?NTS#R{3RCsy;w{mqpJ7N%G-qo z7!IqCK$4QJLqct#d5dqrnS^;W_iq_b?EHixy zMKz6R+E(Cf}klGmP*Gd#a(Def_EO7IU4fmjO^;?Tw99ZXXL{> z1I=N^2cIbx#L8RWB#p>T&1>6bKw?C8VWi4s4zLLGQmOwoxDRHQ@)FFT-6VQs`xm5!m{@RJbFQWwxWncq3zn-(waUSn{(5hxnM=P>ox-l2*F5(AD}p1F@*YSRWwG;a z&}_)?jOH-Cv&;9V`)l#WpZgXm1GwOh<`ivHfo}t$n>#}vYv8aw;%?a2h<87_$0F8s z;G!d{Z~Dihp8z_Zn{^%qFP=rVo&Xv|#Nf5BLq}hpbquvC&8%cjT5u$s5A6Mn8%se9 z4AVF&=rTDu;{cL~4w|rtRwF2!%Ly9_0_2Dke zU<-D59uk%pb8_uf34--=#F9VWThA9zXSE<*Bn@PFusc9=;tjYi{*NVbdfxi=+q}Ev zz;;}>^xCUV7#Ea-6WMn#!94_#LE_Znb&`QKu4!j^Rl!$+p|{%3x93Cn7m%W%+96E7;fppTpwAD?P0%iOSx5;nU>#)wIQgH+|kx>|fj zHS#$U-Y6g}mQOHno2$MXD>psn; zHkNOurd5eFXFgDovmc_X>KC?4aTj$In!T@pt{@ZC?x8EMy+~V0@91ihy$>0nK6L?8 zbj2rT&J|pCFy*8mW2+=ogGc9w;p)K1Ek?jJ$2-`s@p^7=)pvkomNA4&&s;ExLTK7M z(fNkeMN{<Z(CQf>;dpfV$6mzm1F(=R!bv-G;vbe_PV&b{&f9ZGw*p1djMZtt%hd=-rv=Ky0((9Y-&ww%yF|3T;B*HOWx?V z(r%-=h4DpOR@DexR#kC+O~`!Gk8*8%eEhY<1XYU4O*p(bO+I z>eVm89T!`TS+MMvXm_|+Qb>Khi#N1%*q#eWE_nHl)IdNViBlWKyY#D_?OZp)p1Qkq zo#%_?9_{<|ot^EL+jF3PqK*F_MgnPMx9ABv%z>)V$MYLZI|M(WL!@gOzl5QGD9X;` zXBkg%4gO4UJ23y)6a8-*m#`Rm`;krFg#I_5FGRAngtVQMMKy%9LLJ3_DQX|>j9#q{ z2rXW)rdd?fBpDl+5A0kS?`F0_USFfqD~P53;$SX2gYN* zEjP83^KGN@IppRFaCaJ8dj9>cVT-1m_l}J*jQ|K8T{jWWG%}tw&CaIf9S+tPMSL+n zaK#v%&YENU6gf#Cwn3u`ZJ?r4DZFBNfK{JWcoG;?cOd0uP4m*{GqAsOCQzrHlfE#| zl<_A_zKP;mF9+KE@xijw^}LL7L<_;7bVJ^J3 zku5l=o&~Q9Wy4j@Ewi~~_5FddI)zM=*uxFLI`7}iRUP2-NutLzCS&PW~A*u+VCnbj=Br6YVhdoB2~3XW*U5gF(7fG<+% zFA+tD%EOzt{SZcG)+Sl8!Zy<(uv(vp`h1oFr=W}4InjFhBv9K`U(EgJ+4a5>y^iZ-aeUDatxh^|DyKkQg8-5Xb{S@?8H$W z)tonhBEXmSNDUtFqpEyWVAN>CR2^ESW&qjPN*bhr&t2u3Q>D@$tUB1*QD^ln%A}z! zJV%6En=$zh#e^r!Rx;?+(WxVBKcbF0Etc(<3Sn#zBR4Yj#P`-HfFXha?B)isg@QeRW=o)iMGJ37UWtY^x8p z^X&xaao)ag*)Z-s5%>A=0OuqIyePa66`7XU2430Hfe&ujo~G=>75v+*H9chX33F>h ziVzZ$QBKRH$Ium+*rr&WoqJ-zpE|SBtj1EX(DK-{6|tbC_X~Zm^-$(5?aZHG68ht> zHLLnvWfC{G^?tr;=_JI2%_=6*X(4*f$I9bE^o&eUoI=iMFAa@%j%vRq`9>qw|7ul^ zncbfK_;j$3*PN$rD~a)JTYK_6Cp^_aregGo|4{qTX8-dZ>|5O$>v3x8-;Tz~6hq(D zpPEd0IkkVlvi`PtstK1b16);^3gvpcy9n^A_~?MrBg**iC|t^y=xRo!8MzaFv5mZq z(c`fjZ?i~8s4*wM)~S3l-PU|PQKk8%W6D-_-kFZ7C^2X%Dr=oy-*3*c7v-yDKhNjp z8BslxqQHk2ov=184SRGeOh>X;Zea4w5-WB12tOZAYinRfZpUbFcuZdFm<%2*poO|< z*;>V6D~e-fO$^7tD7EP%V1%OHx8{e9QK7r)a2IL*xr<7fgEfPWBV-v#O|oo-<^Zk> zWXYtP8;z>dm+~bkYyTxW_r)&+Cmg*5B1r7dxT`Ri4kN&SHTMh0-eH^+w{&{^{@R9x ziqE=&dmx+iLMO?!G4;^AHmLsm?+Wlc)*3kXC<($b4quSQ_`GcrK$)1Q#WFF{Ky@5U z=tn$Q$7eExMP>Ii+u9d{seR2G_u0koOt?ODChs+gTcSX8T!LF!)rbS$gb%!Weut$g z`cn+*HY^%*P7<4X>KC({8wXlEEz11q1outh1lcm9O4#d&Rp98!s;azvkkSKt@iLc> zp7^B}$(vyq{UnuHecemfBZ0^_!|>8i8l}(%pY-1>U+#AK~rM{4Xc((2Cv zj0bFA7h;kgd1bsPSQt1RBvp}NDlS{vpZDuWDHf4`>NwlPYi@8Zo}lpDp60?c1S zft|+2$AU|_8;ceP_6N*jy2h1dc6TvFxh>NW23x(a=l{bW!BDal(!WVpQiy$t8`p>H;fizo z!KeCOY;kC;84JMJfI}&w=&{X!9xIQ3o95ZGiu!!r$nHAA*NyZdlWc3-J|`OOl)2;> z^plYz|29*NXEQZ5J}vVi4|puIl&rCEDCY~+`HGLS{3C-%M!`10!j$ndrca2B9_(4L z^Uc%u2TgsOqKW0vl&+HOZ|_46co1qN^UiFlH{GeM!4;XTejBdp&tYv@PwTrid zc0u2XqTgnj$8(RD+03>q_Kz~ys;{v^jOtu@*3dM-Dp5)|V38kZ&YhD}K&i&}!66N) z2`75G@#Hfam;9U}bL+x)tK~-8=P;T$4rZ0zH~;`owT(&zTYBSXyCn`iG#)~ju`71;h4abr69 z${?vqpOy|+hfR;c)iExS1T4x^8vi~yJm>6l*-t2XvwW;12O-mIJknYUQfy%g{T!aU z1~o|n=!A0bCJA;~jk6(MWxDokR&|y3N-zV5B*>3X|2~BMO(dh;SCn6fSbIhTQ^WggMj@Y2lam*b78RU<0bH`>m7P;6W=F)5P9}62 zUqSh9o=-IGN?p_2oieQEGdp z35hE9d#<0Y&m&ql`zV-fr*^Hyl@D@y#=j8?(HXD&{Q--EP2F$UL*`xUaCu6hL?SLk z06Pnzp>SF%pb4G2in@mi8F^l%G^9j1+v|IVT3NF;rgjKRJSA(&*(J5?St3-XfxGa} z=__gtfx!w*A)adK*Um)VsyF9==sPQn&qa>E&;qvT6STKoX-{;>SQ#;eJOEV&u~!(3M-4R^-AN z6Wfi5eoQwF4l{xw08SDJME`Eg^X)x;}58UxBG*(+W85UFB@D}WqNS`m_$tA|08AM%-qRmNQF-x9G zVkZc^mIQ7BwTg1S^oC&la`ws}TTG&w&sVlF5R*JQ58F?6H{#-Ux7Kq+$_&b ziq4?La%)D8?MdOGOY=|} zX(OxD-W`&qe1ML|p=YhXZ9mP!b*5{+#Y|hw#FORLq3Q791R3BM**!egzbE`;;07XQFfx;3%@&Cwe zn@fNLGz<_>S~z_Q0TBK_FZ5MF4W)#RtKSE4uXhe+(05MGuU#e0KxP`y^ubjC*Z)Ur zLt6thprT0t)0>e1X?bxGX5fDxW)A|~|Gq^*62hXQ|6roRk`iM7Wa28`HE&gBeq7q`De+Np4Nc<~V zQe6CBOiJosMN6imt^>&UB|-oG6G<`AfAu5vpT^UpHUVnF|NCI%G0I|b>I#-G5@As`JyIUpq^(jh}gHwZ%uDqTYe zDBSnE_pWu<_rBjf|D3b--p^ipJ?D?}tTW!ngy>^>4abJ#z;WUC;CPMruw-m-mL3@n zeY0*d{ts*bCH7Q=fA(CFlDB8UL+-EZn)Q}z^ux*E7ARwRC+c=ZA6p(4(YY8vqJ zvVEV(3jRtaroxWsUfZzv63&O>#!?AE*J@GHp2e33RTn-x?;0;smSRpuW9oa?5Imii zNZ$PbtI-d1D}SUP%1Lc6L22xReH{J<5o?U7mZj?IV zeis`s>Iqr*%h|b--cwZ55$OUOU#5wf?5r2pvwsx}bXKvWRcXL~fT+3Gtl7R`&2iMH z$j1T9i)@OgYqX~PTw2LHIJ9e*A~0mqeHqZOvUqUl(+*krW4wZZ&9GP~>{95uRG2a3 zq??I@CLxT^liZNIVZPs10Ev(99XN$T6X%t4zgTU_Bnuv*7}&_dE?R`AzTLjELLPv8 zACO$XK1QSx7!)Sv-EqW{baqttm}~y>u-E}+1{*Wpcc01unnZZ|gLAgpzxB5W-}P|~ zOxmcq|Mh`^3Xa>^*9`+*7jX^C;~46vLzwl$s<`cypzY;Sc55A= z^(yFU%Cru0wi-Zh!m(5R!yL>sU1>YO&pR)TBv)^+v_*S84&{`OOL!#N)5*P~J4tk!mu{^kFRtG1of4rJ|u<A60yhu`g73z8MMwcDz~L zeFrNCk>TlT&rfT=jJOWvIHT1lwH{KhmURs|i7}!3ZTDM9y@J_9)EETmCj)(=6;2#p zQtC#7}>r zrXIZxmwhYp7^!@Sq!*OJ3|t~_ILD?VUJ^OiojSa1=RWclb8RemKK=#$aN1E~gRN-Q3lC3x$?SYEZQ6-=J|@X?E=|Zs5|aH>wkRh# z>5>tVKpvoEOW&{b)kYvP84KT zjKWWe%A%FQ(`y+;xw#r5cpXM3Sz%w`_Qku^Ry|7I{c`f1B_H&uil)HkYs;jPYSpQH zZ!rr|w+KQ@AOT51&*0!%Zsfkg`a6kMF#cwo3B|KjlpU+}WpV37{p5ZQ&j@&WD|>P@ z#vk>oK>A}U1r3B&UCVRHE;kBqfkVSOIIMQyNgyR^V@1r?q{+!5et_LgfyGurpm_)V z=w;u&;-m}ySaHyz^3F~^XUe)-y&AL?>EFBW@I6``Ak%O*=~Mh|``l-p^S6>r%b8&5 zQ+pU-kv?5dAcydc^%t{1I858NOv}(WDIhnVZ*xpZ^CUX=bfkF6+8kTca!s2O%m|E0 zW=lOi|8=qz2p@W1f);)-x~mC4^LoC;-}6E-`};te@yGO-`(L6Vni9lpz9l)#hqC8p z1>XpT0gdjY@R}0khDALyWM2v|Z!&K4MHVPyuuPDnmo_(l{REoO36x~n{KCuk)4(WRl z*Z=OlpUt<&@O1wk?Ba;|Apsr^)4;&Na5FT&o}_d-4CHB)3(DAg6O_#?igRty+cvjz zWLDeHo7-ybw=U8+Eka<%SbulhnIs^7P5ZqLwJ0RWMP-z5SZ5R1>dp3eV@(3?S!25l zG}bm02T*a4`b=dX`;>Gm%$T=SF*#3mkG6CxOyl-31k{`a?*ngV^<9jl ztuowpG*!R&;!J%eS9NR&x^w+jY70#nI4U6>hG>?6xH z*4ij5n!+AJ_Qh`RM4hA@Mo?;@*Zqfp@?965C~x$0_W(w1Y8@ifVPYd`wPLQ7T*c-L z^X%i+cnLg`8k{9ZSDB-=Ad`pBfn= ztAij2XI>6K_D{i9k`H8m{p5Qwc;Sw&U%Rf>z~XQQ;oZaSjcO?S>ycDGyMhC%3d)KB zsly7L=KvPXN}HC1FNHpwrtW$xu`K13nzWk`CqWxbM6jnnzt}`f9^^B>NVY>>MzP2~ z-uCV&ghwTVTre7cs+d+yQtwUnNpz)`CcPt**5cDM*4BL6+PX8kp}k^pnemY$np zr!w8BZR`Wb@Hzc-UX2)w@L(z)@2~Zwk6-xjg^2HSgzd8IhP44e`c_K*6p6aTtCkY; zFSJh4TcO_1)%XkVW7ck#L$_6)D{lE*oL?r8-&M|f#sIeg7w1b+*}rR%zY^Y7*vK&cOKk|;DO~2 z5eI(;6x%rV1(-5vJqp0X!#L-$k8j3g_Ug?G`j*MoYiSR zuwX8&b>6vrm)p+TB|etm>`~mHVWhl6ot0&rw}KX$a(r~*?3IYspG2G5~c z&rQD?g{-9ya84GA|69r?3cxzL;u%Q5ej`jQl*RDge9GqZef@_XP zu{!lB2_`U!on=BsB1S#5kND_Wpw*cVfvq-}SSb=ld^2W_CL0>Ih^wx7JOQ-zSS=Nr zk4Cl)<+cr0IeUG^7OI1Ctcy1CQ@>B)^&QEiA%=i~E=*T5fz*{m<0mFm3wvt7Jp6V) z-)pPp1Hf5RR3}rwtpC14+epvSVHnPk7ViPNY`m|M=qbeQMP3ZbFDBHPr&K~VDup(2 z6gmBz8Qid7kVHJpuy=~*#mnbAq&lUm56K#r`dM~e*u7A=K=V+MEZXgm5@zKD6Daq6 zDo6|=59kxFAL6$#HnlP;Em?Lu&9(U;EGpTs3w**9CML3f?Fkyx&+e&0hf-OJS!RF~ zgl5Xi!LG{)yVf@|8flZ4JCN+^hrc98dVohl!R%g-}ElAXrP<8k_h570cq z=7N2!6@%q7dk7P%*Z>gB*w>dftm7a6G}e;!nqh>F8r0}n<>O#~cU6po=@TBF6r8!c zjs^-O&Mvv`(i@X{VX(Xv;I{zs}i@T$(v zt@rheCJV=!e7bLi*zR{+gCRWPSXaIBoN8v>(7X`Luf+$e^=bwB5`%^&uXyO$xmpoX zVgl7^h9-MLy%@v5gb|RSUHam$3Ij{Avt2y%t53uzJYyk3jT&hzj*;i)R+g3#p0o84k*x zZ3dO6V76C5^(MyxwW7@P1gyV3?Mv%n( zN~bXETFEhB3fCOZ)jy~oG&G8@)ZZWA8;o^%x2ZVm!we}YgGo^rK!1Yd1(LlqMg$v2 zf!6$-h*9=w+&60JbsI z!1ZLd(U@{I&`sSa;E5tNVEFyOf~@{q#>vYcG5m=&^xeka?D;?E0xo6hnj@zvkFZ|5+=2rf++ zY47evnYsm*l@NMrAH(9RhRj@CKK-b@xCk+m>LXZwKdv?ODa}!_2_RE=SU(r8jQpxk z2$?#-lPY3iRq_t%A3(43O9QZ2+Q(S;G@JQ77%|7|_C|Qcsz%D132y38xPz#nGB;CE z8I`7T))NORCmP&ADq^@d1&Fy{VZnqO2SpxxjbOo(OLs&yhRm;z){(w-TN^*!xuyEX z!`IJI9MX`Zqg>4j+<6;VBRk7DUox@6h6?&er*aNn_{+WOHh6vYX#KVF+pEl_z zb$MI*iY*ZNX3L0|=z>mKwnn>JK*u8Go6CK_MV3?~l!`Qnd8+l`Bd6_5-MGday|C!> zz>_BnOgsFLJdcJF-Gmo;f#>oX&+N$6#3}MPyr>^=UNutQ2dc09=XtK>g)-%8%!Kdi zbyO6jP>4E1HtH;q9_~FC603|yFXYxnrhmteiZ#qxLJgmH&GsM;?Uek{+LtYF*@`AJ zQX*g_jh{_NyYX}^=BSIL@Z*lVjUJGG z-Q^b__dOWrl=*>NEyoNwseS>+UuRboJU(}`u_0*wXl1+}&5-@stHI{b8(@WX;f`0MB)Vf`X~oT1XHzqA zfGr{j`2O_t#3P7Tv-m4@R|g`i@bYsQc2IUd(q*)ut?*e5F4p1deDAA$(4b&7WfBcE zygl`ISfI|IxbuvnE|t`JI=(j%9=kuV%HIF=Q=$7dgL>o5Cu(e^IqIG_=hWECPr^Ug zDSFyJ;JO4Lg&eP9qcF3-R`_$O2wwNC5*!b^*CYU|WcbIxVb>W5yj;2F$r+wY}X~_CX2SjOz$TCiI zq>^vaL!u%H)G#-^)!?=A>Z-S4mWwWM#C;3NQIQQKL{CzA?$`M(Pyo;o6KwjDI%9dP zSueifv`y?ddbFp1X^{>eCMU*emv)(pgTCO~Y(i&B-v@-<>Cl~iUWWlTm+X1kz0lv+ z4kp+Yf7Tn{GC8^rm>FyRLSBEb2G1Q9Pt;bDX^M!I63283b41eeQkLCevl?L z_UtpDdPt2p7Z-nskVA1DRp>tBG7n}B-Y_#8HLQd-Z)qT)Nq#Ssb|th5cFc4twU5LT zaEzT_KKJY9`z^iwsjfDth1}nVypHaW5D!Jp5~Wha1J|X_*)nU{oFUaY7<2UCQ{o=` z!r(FoW>cFBKP6+l1()D&m|Y-)G99@w`tyKO_WNCR8VQMsCk|pvT?io%J3Af4rquc) z@lWh63)sr?>t4rVP0^Lo6G$LqHx+i&G3c|{eauBI#lf2empPSR{WgIsQp!ZwcUan{ zb|I-~mrvh&aXepx+qFx6a~1;(c=CilvX5c4ZN>W57Hh{qX`+9Vx0>P`VX&eQV-E0g zhlcQUlvP+bmCO#{X`9Yn4=pcx)-<0mwAi(Hu*@pogVOJDwb{I$wo3QxDwb-_*!!%y ztSTM~qT>~OHscpbZe>8TvUsdQn+~eMfAHm|n4qgy(3YAI8PYs^;>k92N8cKi7jQ)6 z;^!w~^BpV~gVH?3V5@5J4N!d6S_R@3(n*6FYs8(}rx%6$g z8`~ud6osvHtbNGPzq=Sb{seTl-&vnrH{H5p$)U2xy4|8tttUczV)ezO5IpDFx(ypv(tj#a3FdPw^^Lj!!Qd=M6jf_`+;27JPjGvg*CV1NvQ(oC zvMM0!1ks$b0Sh;f1Vzsc#cU^W>+V539ZDPlgY@{bje8@^QI18aj2)S|G?pY|wai%&KyZ%r6VE{=C)r=vd7aTb1p1 z(u|*CgxO_|W8X<l_Ban`&C^Py+7DgajL{t>6fVaLO{KOrX}1QZS{JelA0##oy1IR$K-aT zHz9(ygdCb?MORHj5B=}_Cwf& zXy~X!J}}SAcX(X~c*4sG-(xD5pq6FVJ>9}n7P_c($2meW6HH|XEAw8hOk_MTtqEJ< z;;c9n#svQ^Z#s&)qxB{LRf^q__wW!tZ{{7xAH2^gA_jq&@e#4J3u}2gDB1csvhylQ zf~@d@a0 zpuVZAUe?7DKF|NdHA9y1>#%XaB3a*8@Fj6XC9*hH@u~Pk*g^kV>>i{<|JtEY5pfv! z@0h5B7`WMT75@ni@OM1~1{0C^yB-XN{KG>G0{(j~R2(ew4;>5)`iCD30{P!s;QxZc zpyK}&iowMH9tI{Z0{aIh0fqb>69-BBBaAp$LiFEsOn-Gq94aC9Z{S~;1PlzxYTdwB f5&6$IBO}Ad&ikLKEYLT6T0#hzh>J^EN9Df&XW$4a diff --git a/work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.typ b/work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.typ index 2094755..3f209ad 100644 --- a/work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.typ +++ b/work/2024/phil-1/paper-1/main.typ @@ -247,9 +247,10 @@ contradiction with BG2. So, if IU5 holds, then BG2 must fail. It's important to note that the Indeterminate Utilities argument doesn't say that the _opposite_ of BG2 is true. It doesn't argue that the expected utility of being an atheist is greater. In fact, it doesn't say anything about the -expected utilities, except that they cannot all be compared. If they cannot all -be calculated, then they cannot be compared. So, we can't say whether believing -in god has a greater expected utility or not. +expected utilities, except that they cannot be compared. If they can't be +compared, then we can't say for certain which option has the higher expected +utility. Since BG2 claims that believing in god must have the higher expected +utility, it is a false premise. = Addressing Objections